Disguising the truth

Mr Marc Seale is the Chief Executive of the HPC. The HPC is a QUANGO - a quasi autonomous non governmental agency. The Longman dictionary definition of this is as follows: set up by a government and having statutory powers in a specific field (eg the race relations board). In this case set up by the Health Professions Order 2001 - HPO2001 - and passed into law by Parliament in early 2002, responsible to, and administered by the Privy Council. Wikipedia adds 'the acronym can carry with it an implication of poor management and lack of accountability.'

At the BSHAA's congress, 18 April 08, Kenilworth, Mr Seale introduced the HPC as 'not a charity'. I wasn't there, but the powerpoint presentation is available on the web to download. One of the slides in his powerpoint show states: Not a charity. The HPC is not a charity. I wonder who might have thought that it was? Perhaps it was a joke, but I wonder why Mr Seale did not take the time given to him by the BSHAA to explain exactly what the HPC was? Perhaps he did in his talk, while his powerpoint projection continued to emit the empty information in large print on the screen that might have dominated the room.

Freud is famous for pointing out that when an analysand says 'it was not my mother' that we are indeed in the domain of the mother. So, is Marc Seale cunningly deploying a trick to subliminally implant the idea into the minds of this potential new source of income that the HPC is indeed a charity? I think we should be told.

The next bullet point on the show said 'the HPC is self financing'. Not a charity, but self financing. This rather suggests that it is competing in the free market and people are freely choosing to purchase its services because they think they are worthwhile. Not at all. Not only is it not a charity, but it is not a regular business, competing alongside a variety of others, either.

The HPC has the power to prosecute people for practising without paying their fee to the HPC. It is underwritten by law to compel money into its coffers through the use of statutory power. Without HPC registration, practitioners cannot use government 'protected' titles. The NHS and its contractors, are obliged to employ HPC-registrants thus creating a Government or Statutorily regulated market.

Why mask the truth in this way?